Italy Fines Meta EUR 805 Million Over Facebook Gallery Access

Italy's data protection authority fined Meta EUR 805 million as a default Facebook Android feature accessed users' photo galleries without explicit consent.
Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante, has fined Meta EUR 805 million, about USD 887 million, over a Facebook feature on Android that accessed users’ photo galleries without specific, informed consent. The penalty equals roughly 0.47 percent of Meta’s global turnover and was announced on November 14.

    What the Garante Found in Facebook’s Gallery Suggestions Feature

    The feature, called “Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook,” was enabled by default. It accessed users’ photos, videos and metadata through a single app-wide permission that covered several functions, so users granting access for one purpose did not give separate consent for gallery suggestions. The fine falls on Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, and the regulator says about 20 million Italian Android users were affected.

    Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code

    The Garante found a breach of Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, the national implementation of the EU ePrivacy Directive. The provision requires free, informed consent before an organization accesses data stored on a user’s phone, and it applies regardless of whether any harm followed.

    Factors That Raised the Penalty

    The authority cited the scale of the feature, its duration since 2023, a 2019 decision against the company and limited cooperation as aggravating factors. The investigation opened in July 2025 after a complaint from the consumer group Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti.

    Compliance Deadlines Meta Faces Under the Order

    Meta must ask for separate consent within 60 days and keep the feature off by default, including for users who previously granted the broader permission. It must report to the authority on its progress at 30 days and again at 90 days. If Meta misses the deadline, it cannot enable the feature for anyone without valid consent.

    Meta Appeals and Disputes Which Regulator Should Lead

    Meta plans to appeal and described the fine as “disproportionate.” The company says the feature works only after users grant permission. It also argued that Ireland’s data protection regulator, where Meta Platforms Ireland is based, should lead the case. The Garante rejected that position because the ePrivacy framework has no one-stop-shop mechanism, which means a national authority can act on its own.

    Questions Left Open on AI Training

    The probe did not examine whether gallery content was used to train AI models. Meta denies any such use. A newer gallery feature that processes content in the cloud may be examined separately.

    Italian Regulator Cites Meta’s 2019 Decision and Limited Cooperation

    The size of the penalty reflects more than the single feature. The Garante counted the feature’s availability since 2023 across a base of about 20 million Italian Android users, the 2019 decision against the company, and what it described as limited cooperation during the probe. The fine amounts to about 0.47 percent of Meta’s global turnover. Meta’s position is that the feature works only after users grant permission, while the regulator’s position is that a permission covering several functions at once cannot stand in for specific consent to one of them.

    What the Italian Fine Means for Platform Consent Design

    The ruling is one of the larger privacy penalties imposed on Meta, and it forces a redesign of the consent flow for Italian Android users. The analytical weight lies in the legal route the Garante chose. Because it relied on ePrivacy rules rather than the GDPR, it avoided the one-stop-shop process that normally channels cross-border cases toward the Irish regulator. Other national authorities enforcing the same Article 122 equivalents in their own countries could, in principle, take the same path against features that bundle device permissions.

    The Bundled Permission Problem in Android Apps

    The central finding is about structure, not just one feature: a single app-wide permission was treated as consent for multiple distinct functions. That design is common in mobile software, and the decision signals that regulators will examine whether each function that touches stored personal data has its own consent. The outcome of Meta’s appeal will determine how firmly that principle holds.

    Related Posts