Judge Acquits Peraire-Bueno Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum Case

A federal judge acquitted MIT-educated brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud charges tied to a $25 million Ethereum transaction exploit.
Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    US District Judge Jessica Clarke entered a judgment of acquittal for Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, former MIT students accused of stealing $25 million in about 12 seconds by exploiting a bug in Ethereum’s transaction validation. The ruling ends a first-of-its-kind prosecution of blockchain transaction manipulation without a conviction.

    Why Judge Clarke Entered the Acquittal

    The judge concluded that the government failed to prove material misrepresentations in the scheme. In her reasoning, the question was not whether the brothers’ conduct was moral or whether it violated crimes that were not charged. The only issue was whether the evidence could support convictions for wire fraud and related offenses, and she found that it could not.

    A Mistrial a Year Earlier Left the Case Unresolved

    The acquittal follows a mistrial about a year ago, when jurors could not agree on a verdict. The judgment of acquittal covers wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering, which means no retrial. It is described as the first US criminal prosecution of MEV, or maximal extractable value, exploitation. Judge Clarke sits in Manhattan, and reports place her ruling on November 16.

    What Prosecutors Alleged About the 2023 Ethereum Exploit

    The brothers were arrested in Boston and New York in May 2024 and charged with wire fraud and money laundering, each carrying up to 20 years per count. Prosecutors said the pair accessed pending private transactions, altered them, took the victims’ cryptocurrency and refused to return it.

    The 12-Second Window and the $25 Million Taken

    According to the prosecution, the scheme took $25 million in about 12 seconds by exploiting a bug in how Ethereum validated transactions. Other reports describe the losers as trading bots rather than individual participants, so the accurate description is that the brothers extracted $25 million from trading bots.

    How the Alleged April 2023 Exploit Used Bait Transactions and a Relay Bug

    As alleged, the brothers placed eight bait transactions to attract sandwich-trading bots. They exploited a bug in the MEV-Boost relay software, setting signature fields to zero, so they could see the bots’ bundled trades before the block was committed. They then built a competing block that replaced the bait with transactions that sold the tokens, netting about $25 million from the bots in roughly 12 seconds.

    Only about $3 million of the proceeds was frozen, and the rest was moved by October 2023. The brothers’ on-chain penalty was about 1 ether, a few thousand dollars, because the validator was penalized.

    Judge Clarke Says Ethereum Is a Trustless Environment With No Terms of Use

    Wire fraud requires a material misrepresentation. Judge Clarke found that bait trades made no binding promises and that the falsified signature had no effect because the relay never verified those fields. She wrote that Ethereum is “a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use.” The conduct may have “frustrated the spirit” of MEV-Boost and may be “improper, objectionable, or even despicable,” she wrote, but that is not enough for fraud. In her words, “The question before the Court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos’ conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes.”

    The first trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025 when the jury deadlocked. It included insider testimony about alleged planning, and the defense tried to block Google search evidence.

    What the Ruling Means for Blockchain Transaction Cases

    The decision closes a prosecution that tested whether manipulating blockchain transactions could be charged as wire fraud. The judge’s focus on the absence of proven material misrepresentations shows where the government’s theory fell short: a fraud charge requires proof of a false statement or its equivalent, and the court found that missing here.

    The ruling does not address the broader moral questions around the conduct, a distinction the judge made explicit. Whether the government will appeal has not been reported.

    The Peraire-Bueno case is one of the few criminal tests of how existing fraud statutes apply to automated, on-chain behavior. Because the outcome rested on the evidence presented rather than a new rule of law, it leaves open how future cases with different facts might be charged or decided.

    Related Posts