The California Privacy Protection Agency fined Hertz about $1.55 million on November 17 for making it hard for customers to protect their data and for not honoring opt-out requests. The agency announced a second settlement the same day, a $218,000 fine against outdoor-apparel maker CC Filson Co.
What the CPPA Says Hertz Did Wrong
The agency alleges three violations by Hertz, which also operates the Dollar and Thrifty brands. Hertz did not process opt-out preference signals, which are automated signals sent from a consumer’s device or browser. It did not explain how it processed them. And it added friction to the opt-out process.
Hertz Agrees to Quarterly Testing and Tracker Reviews
Hertz agreed to the fine and to change its practices. Those commitments include quarterly testing and monitoring, a review of all new tracking technologies, and opt-out compliance testing. A Hertz spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The Same-Day CC Filson Settlement Targets Ad-Tech Data Sharing
The CPPA also announced a $218,000 settlement with CC Filson Co. Under its terms, the company must stop device-based sales and sharing of personal information to ad-tech companies. The two actions together cover both ends of the problem: a company that failed to honor opt-out signals, and a company that sold and shared data with advertising technology firms.
CalPrivacy’s Message on Listening When Californians Say No
Lara Kehoe Hoffman of CalPrivacy said businesses have long been on notice that regulators expect them to listen when Californians say no to trackers. The statement frames the Hertz action as enforcement of an existing expectation, not a new rule.
CPPA Finding That Hertz Sites Kept Sharing Data Despite Opt-Out Signals
According to the agency’s decision, for part of a three-year period the Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty websites kept passing visitor data to advertising technology companies even when browsers sent an opt-out signal such as Global Privacy Control. The CPPA cites the California Consumer Privacy Act, and the failure to tell consumers how the signals were processed is a separate alleged violation.
Compliance Actions Hertz Must Take Across Hertz, Dollar and Thrifty
Beyond the fine, the order requires quarterly testing of the methods Hertz offers for submitting CCPA requests. Hertz must also keep an inventory of tracking technologies, with a review process for any new addition across the Hertz, Thrifty and Dollar platforms. Opt-out compliance must be tested across staging and production environments, browsers and mobile devices, and Hertz must include opt-out preference signal metrics in its CCPA request postings.
The decision names enforcement attorneys Lisa B. Kim and Gary Lee of the Enforcement Division and research technologists Nikita Samarin and Primal Wijesekera.
Filson’s $217,987 Fine Reflects Inability to Pay a Larger Penalty
In a separate Board decision, CC Filson Co. received an administrative fine of $217,987. Filson must stop all device-based sales and sharing of Californians’ personal information with advertising technology companies within 30 days and until it certifies compliance, and it faces audits, tests and trainings. The fine amount reflects confidential financial information indicating that Filson could not pay a multi-million dollar penalty.
What the Hertz Fine Signals About Browser Opt-Out Signal Enforcement
The Hertz case centers on opt-out preference signals, the automated mechanism that lets a consumer set a privacy choice once in a browser or device instead of clicking through a form on each site. The agency’s allegations treat a failure to process those signals, a failure to explain the processing, and added friction in the opt-out flow as separate problems.
The enforcement signals stricter treatment of these browser signals. By pairing the Hertz fine with the CC Filson settlement on the same day, the agency showed that it is acting on both the consumer-facing opt-out experience and the downstream data flows to advertisers.
For companies that operate consumer-facing websites in California, the Hertz settlement terms offer a concrete picture of what the agency expects after a violation: regular testing, review of new tracking technologies before deployment, and verification that opt-out signals work as intended.
